Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Andy Esbenshade
REALTOR®, GRI, ABR,ASP,CNE, E-Certified,Realtor
(717) 615-4874
Office: (717) 393-0100
Realtor
Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Instagram Icon 

Customer Testimonials

Submit a Review
  • 5 stars
    105
  • 4 stars
    4
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

Andy Esbenshade
(109 ratings)
5 out of 5 based on 109 ratings.
109 user reviews.
testimonial quote

Andy has been our Realtor for over 12 years. He really has taken his time getting to know us and our needs, especially as we have grown our family along the way! We have had a wonderful experience working with Andy and will continue to do so if we have any other moves planned in the future!

CARLY BYERS
October 25, 2025
testimonial quote

Andy helped us with both of our Lancaster home purchases and was always very supportive and communicative. We would recommend him to anyone!

Scott Vine
June 17, 2025
testimonial quote

My wife and I had the pleasure of working with Mick to purchase both our first and second homes. He has a great way of offering thoughtful input during home tours without ever being pushy. Mick is highly professional, easy to communicate with, and incredibly patient throughout the entire process. We highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

gmweaver4
June 2, 2025
testimonial quote

We have purchased five homes with Andy as our realtor over the past 16 years. From elegant townhouses to modest rental properties Andy knows the business inside and out. When problems arose Andy was there to solve the issue. When we sold properties Andy got us top dollar. He is the consummate professional in every situation and we count him as more than just our realtor- we count him as a friend. JR and Peggy Ankney

JAMES R. ANKNEY
April 27, 2025
testimonial quote

We were first time house-sellers. Working with Andy Esbenshade was simple and effective. We listened to his professional insights, and our house was under contract within a few days.

Teresa Duffy
January 3, 2025
testimonial quote

We were first time house-sellers. Working with Andy Esbenshade was simple and effective. We listened to his professional insights, and our house was under contract within a few days.

TERESA DUFFY
January 2, 2025
testimonial quote

They did great work and when very professional and yes I would recommend them to someone that I know

LARRY GRAVER
December 21, 2024
testimonial quote

Good service. Attentive. Answered questions or provided information for who to contact for answers.

Stephe Deppen, Executor
November 22, 2024
testimonial quote

This is the second home we've bought with Andy's help. He made the process painless and quick. Andy's extensive and exhaustive knowledge is a real benefit to buyers. He's also one of the nicest people you'll ever meet!

christopher caruana
November 6, 2024
testimonial quote

This is the second home we've bought with Andy's help. He made the process painless and quick. Andy's extensive and exhaustive knowledge is a real benefit to buyers. He's also one of the nicest people you'll ever meet!

Christopher Charles Caruana
November 2, 2024
testimonial quote

Patricia Epps
July 31, 2024
testimonial quote

Andy was exceptional in every way!

Patricia Epps
July 30, 2024
testimonial quote

Andy is one of the most knowledgable agents you'll encounter. His years of experience and local expertise are evident in the way he conducts business. Great agent and fantastic referral partner!

Derek “Dr. Google” Bicksler
July 1, 2024
testimonial quote

Andy was kind, compassionate to my situation, very helpful and available at early hours as that fit my schedule better. I would recommend him to anyone purchasing a home.

DAWN COX
June 14, 2024
testimonial quote

Andy is kind, very helpful, wise about the Lancaster real estate market..and makes himself available to make you feel you are his only client. I would recommend him to anyone purchasing a home.

Dawn Cox
June 14, 2024
testimonial quote

Why not help yourself out of hardship and low income, contact Mrs. Helen Paul today and begin trading with just $1,000 and earn as much as $12,250, as she is a genius in trading and helped me improve my standard of living through trading now, I don't have to wait for my monthly salary, just in less than a week I get good profit of 12,250 weekly with the help of her trading software I highly recommend her crypto services to everyone, you can contact her directly on Email: helenpaul3311@gmail.com WhatsApp: +1 (607) 371-6296

Zandih Ndile
April 5, 2024
testimonial quote

Andy Esbenshade and his team did a great job working with us to buy our home from out of state. This is the fourth house we bought using Andy and every time, he made it a seamless experience. His knowledge of Lancaster, his professionalism, and his ability to understand what we were looking for are what make Andy such a great realtor. We are more than pleased!

Peggy Ankney
March 29, 2024
testimonial quote

Andy Esbenshade and his team did a great job working with us to buy our home from out of state. This is the fourth house we bought using Andy and every time, he made it a seamless experience. His knowledge of Lancaster, his professionalism, and his ability to understand what we were looking for are what make Andy such a great realtor. We are more than pleased!

MARGARET ANKNEY
March 28, 2024
testimonial quote

Andy was professional, knowledgeable and helpful every step of the way. He made the process smooth and was an invaluable resource for us. We have worked with him in the past and there is no one better! We would recommend him to anyone. Thank you for a wonderful process and outcome! We so appreciate your time and talent. Thanks again

KELLY Xentaras
March 2, 2024
testimonial quote

We had an excellent experience working with Homesale and Andy Espenshade to get our house sold. Andy was very helpful in guiding us through the sale process, keeping us up to date on its progress, and ultimately getting our house sold within 30 days of listing. We highly recommend the Homesale Team.

Jane Morrison POA Lois J Plauger
February 12, 2024
testimonial quote

Andy was great to work with. Always kept me well informed with his positive actions and helpful guidance. I highly recommend Andy Esbenshade if you are buying or selling property. He’s well known in the community with many helpful contacts to help your move be worry free!

KIM REINFRIED
January 30, 2024
testimonial quote

I earned much (18,500USD) just yesterday from a right source with the help of mrs Joan Steve broker. very fast and reliable. quick cashout. Contact her to get started.. Dm Email:joansteve42@gmail.com WhatsApp:+13017502458

Joyce Pam
September 28, 2023
testimonial quote

Everything is 100%authentic she is very helpful and answers any questions about online trading I just made my 5th withdrawal and it is absolutely stunning and in great condition! Wonderful customer service! Her customer service is beyond expectations! Contact her via: Email: brianlisa953@gmail.com WhatsApp: +1 (334) 231-2298 Fb: Brian Lisa Fx Trader

Thabo Man
September 14, 2023
testimonial quote

I was dreading the whole home sale process. Andy made the prep and sale of the house a smooth operation. His advice, recommendations, and knowledge of the industry greatly reduced the stress, and the sale turned out far better than anticipated.

The Estate Of George C. Uhlric
July 5, 2023
testimonial quote

I was dreading the whole home sale process. Andy made the prep and sale of the house a smooth operation. His advice, recommendations, and knowledge of the industry greatly reduced the stress, and the sale turned out far better than anticipated.

The Estate Of George C. Uhlric
July 5, 2023
testimonial quote

This comfortable and good standard of living I now enjoy with my family, is all thanks to you ma'am Emilia Williams before now I had a low income and did a lot of online trade which no profit, but you can like an angle and change all of that in just one week, you turned my $600 to $8,450 with your intelligence as an expert and from that day I had made more profit each week investing more, no amount of thanks will be enough for what you have done for me and my family, but I promise ma'am I will speak of your honesty, handwork, and trust to the world, this is dream come true for me for finding a legit account manager like you, I advise the entire public to invest with MRS EMILIA WILLIAMS Contact her now WhatsApp: +1 814 822 4004 Email: emiliawilliams247@gmail.com

Christoph Fiston Subga
January 6, 2023
testimonial quote

Am short of words for the amazing profit you helped me earn in just a week, am so sorry I doubted you at the beginning, Mrs. Emilia Williams it was because of my past experience so I didn't know who to trust, I invested $700 and earned $6,900 in just one week, and kept on investing more, today I am financially successful, you can contact her Email: emiliawilliams247@gmail.com WhatsApp: +1 814 822 4004

Christelle Kima
December 12, 2022
testimonial quote

Andy did a wonderful job in selling my parents home . He was supportive as a husband, and with the very sad business of helping my brothers and I part with our parents home. Lisa Esbenshade

Lisa Jones Esbenshade Executor
September 30, 2022
testimonial quote

This is the second property Andy sold for me. He did an excellent job keeping me informed and walking me through the process of online paper work.

Donald Gehman, Poa
April 27, 2021
testimonial quote

I've worked with Andy for many years and will do so again.

Cynthia Krom
April 11, 2021
testimonial quote

I appreciated Andy’s input and professionalism in selling my parents home. It was a pleasure to work him,

Missy Walton, Poa
April 11, 2021
testimonial quote

Andy is a class act and expert in the game. He went above and beyond and truly exceeded our expectations. It's very clear why he's a top agent in Lancaster County.

Zach Sinz
March 31, 2021
testimonial quote

Andy did a great job. Condo was under agreement in 2 weeks and settled in 24 days!

Gregory Schreder
March 12, 2021
testimonial quote

Very responsive, great to work with, extremely professional and above all, very experienced. We highly recommend Andy.

Mark & Mary Vergenes
December 22, 2020
testimonial quote

Andy did a great job. Very much available, attentive, communicated frequently and was always prompt.

Dominick J D'orazio
October 30, 2020
testimonial quote

Andy was instrumental in us buying our new home after we were told previously that it wouldn't work out. Andy led us in the right direction every step of the way. He was prompt, responsive, and answered every question clearly, with easy to understand answers. Would highly recommend to our friends, and we will definitely use Andy again in the future.

Anthony Burke & Leigh Ann Smith
October 23, 2020
testimonial quote

Thank you for your help! Glad we finally made the move to find a house that’s just right for us

Joshua R Myket & Carolyn A Zellem
October 23, 2020
testimonial quote

Andy and his team worked tirelessly to sell our business property during very challenging times. Andy kept us in the loop with information about potential buyers and offered suggestions that enhanced our property's sales potential. We were extremely happy with Andy and his team and would not only recommend him to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, experienced real estate professional, we will use Andy in the future should the need arise.

Douglas & Kathleen Phillips
June 29, 2020
testimonial quote

Andy was professional and thorough! We so appreciated the way that he explained each step of the process of buying a house. He was so knowledgeable and it was amazing to have him as a resource and source of advise! We would highly recommend Andy to our friends and family and felt very lucky to get to work with him so closely and utilize his skills!

Christian & Kelly Xentaras
May 26, 2020
testimonial quote

This was a tough time to sell the condo, in the middle of the pandemic...….Andy and NIcola were very good to work with....my only recommendation is a suggestion to have a weekly conference call between seller, Andy and Nicola, to ensure everyone is on the same pageAndy is very knowledgeable and his network is extensive! Thank you.

Susan C D Suter
May 19, 2020
testimonial quote

Absolutely hands down the best agent I have worked with in the past 20 years! Very respectful, professional, and honest.

Gregory & Suzanne Knowles
March 16, 2020
testimonial quote

Andy really understood what we were looking for and found ya the perfect house! He answered all my questions and was reassuring along the way!

Megan Brill
January 31, 2020
testimonial quote

Very professional, all aspects went very smoothly.

Alan Swanson & Linda Rugel
December 11, 2019
testimonial quote

We appreciate tremendously the professional approach and patience of Mr Andy Esbenshade in the way he helped us secure our new property in Lancaster County, PA. I would most definitely recommend him to any new potential buyers seeking to buy a home in Mannheim Township. Thank you once again Andy and we will keep in touchHector&Carmelina Bonavia7 Deer Ford Drive,LancasterZip Code 17601

Hector & Carmelina Bonavia
November 5, 2019
testimonial quote

Andy Esbenshade offers a unique combination of professionalism, experience, knowledge and friendliness that assures us we are working with the best. We are particularly grateful for the honesty and integrity Andy brings to all of our real estate conversations. We could not have picked a better agent.

John & Jessie Scala
October 28, 2019
testimonial quote

Andy has been great through this whole process. Great follow through. Encouraging when chips were down. Very happy with the outcome of the sale. Just an overall excellent person and agent. I recommend Andy to everyone I know.

Doreen Landis & Stephanie Bennett
October 24, 2019
testimonial quote

Andy Espenshade did, yet again, a phenomenal job with the help of purchasing our home, from first walk through to after the deal was complete.

Charles Brommer & Jaclyn Downs
September 28, 2019
testimonial quote

Andy Esbenshade and his team were top notch. Sold my house in three days above asking price.

Brian C & Karen L Lehr
August 9, 2019
testimonial quote

Andy and Nicola are outstanding. Andy is extremely pleasant, patient and knowledgeable and I would highly recommend him to anyone in need of real estate services. Mark Henry was also very helpful and efficient in assisting me with the insurance side of things.

Thomas Yu
July 12, 2019
testimonial quote

This was the first time I ever sold a house! Both Andy and Nicola were very responsive to my questions. Andy helped me understand the current housing market, where the sale of my home fit in, what basics I needed to do to get it ready, and what to expect from the process. This kind of knowledge helped make me more confident in the whole process. Andy could be reached by email, text and through his assistant - this meant that I got the information when I needed it. We scrambled to get the house ready because it was clear that it was the right time, and the effort was worth it. The people involved in the settlement process we are also very helpful. THANKS! Christina

Christina T Miller
June 28, 2019

Share Your Experience

The experience you've had in working with me is important. Please take a few moments and share how your experience was so I can share it with others.

Review Submission Form
  • Markets:
  • 1 Stars2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 05/22/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 05/22/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Fri 05/22/2026 12:27:58 AM EST) or Bright MLS (last updated Fri 05/22/2026 12:22:21 AM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility
Federal Housing Equal Opportunity Realtor
Corporate Office - 215 S Centerville Rd. Lancaster, PA 17603
James J Hafer - West Virginia Broker of Record

©2026 BHH Affiliates, LLC. An independently owned and operated franchisee of BHH Affiliates, LLC. Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices and the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices symbol are registered service marks of Columbia Insurance Company, a Berkshire Hathaway affiliate. Equal Housing Opportunity.


Agent License Information: 
Licensed in Pennsylvania
Andy Esbenshade 

215 S. Centerville Road, Lancaster, PA 17603
717-393-0100

Login to Saved Search

Pixel